Quick answer: To work out how to tell if a painting is original, start with raking light and a loupe, then check the reverse and the paperwork. Call a conservator or expert when the value is high or doubts remain.
This guide covers the authenticity step before a purchase. For the wider buying picture, see how to start collecting fine art.
Choosing between a home check and an expert
A buyer can rule out many prints and weak offers alone, but only an expert can support a firm attribution. The right route depends on four things.

- Price against the artist. An abnormally low price for a work by a listed artist is the first warning sign, according to a provenance guide for art buyers. Treat a bargain as a reason to examine more closely, not less.
- What the surface shows. Raised paint ridges point towards an original. Regular dots or rosettes point towards a print.
- What the paperwork shows. Labels on the reverse and a documented ownership chain can support the picture. They cannot replace examining the object.
- Who stands behind the sale. Galleries that belong to professional bodies offer substantial guarantees. Some auction clauses limit guarantees on authenticity or provenance and shift part of the risk onto the buyer.
The table sets the main checks side by side so you can decide what to do first.
| Check | What it can reveal | Limit | Planning use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Raking light (flashlight held at a low angle) | Raised ridges in highlights and thick passages | Shows how the paint sits, not who painted it | Do first; it costs nothing |
| Loupe at 10x | Inkjet dots or offset rosettes mean a modern print | Does not date or attribute an original | Use to rule out reproductions quickly |
| Canvas weave | Consistency with an older or newer support | A clue, not proof | Note it, never decide on it alone |
| Reverse of the frame | Labels, dates and construction | Labels can be read only as evidence, not as a verdict | Photograph before any purchase |
| Certificate of authenticity | Identity of the work and its creator, as attested by the issuer | Only as reliable as the issuer | Ask who issued it and on what basis |
| Expert examination | Materials, techniques, condition, consistency with the catalogue raisonné | Cost and time | Commission when value or doubt is high |
The surface checks follow Appraisily’s guide to originals and prints, and the certificate and expert rows follow the provenance guide.

Surface checks you can do yourself
The surface is the quickest evidence a buyer can gather without equipment beyond a phone light and a cheap loupe.
Raking light and the loupe
Hold a flashlight (a phone works) at a low angle across the painting. In an original, distinct raised ridges appear where brushstrokes should be, especially in highlights and thick passages. Raised impasto is hard to fake convincingly, so ridges you can see and feel carry real weight.
Next, look through a 10x loupe. Most modern prints resolve into dots (inkjet) or rosettes (offset printing). A flat, evenly dotted surface is a reason to stop treating the piece as a painting.
Canvas weave and reproductions
Canvas weave is a clue, not proof. Reproductions can be printed on canvas, so a visible weave should be read together with the ridges and the dot test above. The distinction matters financially: signed original prints can be valuable, while reproductions of paintings rarely are.
Signatures and edition marks
A signature is an entity to be tested, not a conclusion. A pencil signature together with an edition number usually indicates a print rather than a unique painting. Hand-signed stickers should not be relied on alone; verify the work with magnification rather than trusting the sticker.
The reverse of the frame and the paper trail
The back of a framed work often holds the best identification clues: labels, dates and the way the frame and stretcher are built. Photograph it fully before any purchase decision.
An unbroken chain of ownership is the best guarantee of legitimacy. Each transfer should ideally be documented by an invoice, a receipt, an auction catalogue or a signed attestation. The guide on what is provenance in art explains how that record is built and read.

When buying remotely, ask the seller for high-resolution photographs from several angles, including the reverse, the signature and any accompanying documents. A seller who cannot supply them has given you information of its own.
What a certificate of authenticity proves
A certificate of authenticity attests to the identity of the work and its creator. It is the starting point of traceability, and it is most useful when issued by the artist, their estate or a recognised expert.
That wording sets its limit. A certificate is a statement by its issuer, so its value depends on who the issuer is and whether the description clearly matches the object in front of you. A certificate from an unknown party, or one that could describe any similar work, proves little. Use it alongside the surface evidence and the ownership record, never in place of them.

Who can authenticate an artwork
Authentication opinions come from the artist, the artist’s estate or a recognised expert. Where an artist has a catalogue raisonné, a scientific inventory of the artist’s output, it constitutes the ultimate reference, and a work’s consistency with it counts for a great deal.
When choosing an expert, favour certified experts who are members of recognised professional chambers. The expert examines the work from every angle: materials, techniques and condition, and consistency with the catalogue. Technical examination of this depth goes beyond the flashlight and loupe, so commission it when the stakes justify the cost.
Different media raise different questions. Stone and carved work, such as shona sculpture, is judged on different physical evidence than paint on canvas.
If you suspect a fake
Act in an order that protects your position before money or goods change hands.
- Document everything. Keep photographs of the front, reverse, signature and any labels, together with the listing and correspondence.
- Repeat the surface checks. Raking light and a loupe can confirm whether you are looking at a print.
- Check stolen-art records. The Art Loss Register, a worldwide registry of stolen works, lists more than 700,000 items.
- Read the sale conditions. Some auction clauses limit guarantees on authenticity or provenance and shift part of the risk onto the buyer, so know what you accepted.
- Obtain an expert opinion. Use a certified expert from a recognised professional chamber.
- Take legal advice. A lawyer experienced in art purchases can advise on German law and on the terms of your particular sale.
Frequently asked questions
How long does a basic surface check take?
About 10 minutes with a flashlight and a cheap jeweller’s loupe, according to Appraisily.
What are artist’s proofs?
They are impressions printed outside the numbered edition, usually marked in pencil with AP, E.A. or H.C. They are prints, not unique paintings.
Does a label saying “lithograph” mean the work is hand-made?
Not necessarily. A label that only says “lithograph” may describe a commercial offset print rather than a hand-drawn original lithograph, and offset printing shows rosette dots under magnification.
Do works from 1933 to 1945 need extra checking?
Yes. Works that circulated in Europe between 1933 and 1945 require particular attention to provenance, according to the provenance guide.
